How dirty is the Hudson River? Riverkeeper has the data
8/11/11 - 5:53 pm
Photo from Riverkeeper's Facebook page.
Riverkeeper, a nonprofit environmental group that advocates for the Hudson River, recently announced the results of a five-year study of water quality in the Hudson. (See Scribd document below for the full study.)
The good news? In the four decades since the Clean Water Act went into law, the river has gotten a lot cleaner. And Riverkeeper's extensive data show that most of the time, in most places, the Hudson is safe to swim. On average, 21 percent of the samples taken by Riverkeeper failed EPA guidelines for safe swimming.
The bad news? That's three times the average failure rate for water samples from the nation's beaches. And during rainfall and catastrophic system failures -- like the one caused last month, when a fire broke out at one of Manhattan's largest sewage treatment plants -- water pollution in the Hudson spikes dangerously, especially near the shoreline.
Most of the pollution is concentrated near the shoreline, and in specific areas, Riverkeeper says:
In many near-shore locations contamination is local and community specific. That’s good news for area residents because local contamination problems lend themselves to local solutions.
The message is being heard loud and clear in Catskill, where an antiquated sewer system spews raw sewage into the Catskill Creek (a tributary of the Hudson) during periods of heavy rain. The village of Catskill has been working for more than a decade on an overhaul of the system that would separate sewage from stormwater, eliminating the need for sewage outfalls into the creek.
The Daily Mail reports that in Catskill, the difference in water quality between dry summer months and rainy periods, when five outfalls spill raw sewage directly into the creek, is dramatic:
“The July survey shows us what we could have if we eliminated sewage discharges to our waterways,” [Riverkeeper boat captain John] Lipscomb said.
Riverkeeper and its supporters are hoping that the release of so much data into the public will lend fresh energy to efforts to clean up the Hudson, and are pressuring local governments to collect and release more water-pollution data as well:
Without water quality data, pollution sources and impacts cannot be identified. We can’t manage what we don’t measure.
Riverkeeper scored a major victory yesterday, when the New York City Department of Environmental Protection agreed to begin releasing online water quality alerts when water pollution spikes. Manhattan news website DNAinfo.com reports:
DEP spokesman Farrell Sklerov said the agency will soon begin releasing testing results online and warning the public when rainfall affects pollution levels.
"We agree that the information can be posted more regularly, and we are in the process of adding harbor water sampling results on our website on a regular basis," said Sklerov.
"We are also looking to design a proactive notification system to be used to alert the public when rainfall may affect water quality."
The Riverkeeper report was widely cited in the news media yesterday. It's always fun, when a big story breaks, to see who ran the best headlines (at least, for hopeless news junkies, it is).
Local media played it pretty safe:
Times Herald-Record: Study on NY's Hudson finds unsafe sewage pollution
Poughkeepsie Journal: Riverkeeper: Sewage renders Hudson unsafe to swim 21% of time
The grande dames of Gotham struck a rather baroquely apoplectic tone:
Wall Street Journal: Sewage Plagues Hudson
New York Times: Sewage Frequently Fouls Hudson River, Report Says
And the New York alts and blogs leaned heavily on the snark button:
Village Voice: The Hudson: Frequently Kinda Poopy
(A most excellent snippet: "This comes at a time when the Hudson is attracting more and more people to swim, boat, and fish in its questionably clear waters. If the water stays poopy, say the experts, people will want to enjoy it less. True, true.")
For our money, it's New York blog Gothamist for the win, with this 100% factually accurate headline:
Want to read the whole report? Curious about how your favorite stretch of the Hudson shoreline fared? Or do you just really love water quality data? Have at it:
|A Catskills forest dweller – the Rosy Maple Moth – Pretty in Pink!|
|Dicentra part II (Two Catskills wildflowers)|
|Dicentra Part I (Bleeding Hearts, or why do plant names change?)|
|A TASTE OF ANEMONE|
|DAFFODIL VS NARCISSUS|
|Frost Warnings... Really?!|
|Spring Redecorating in the Henhouse|
|Spring Slinking in Slowly|
|Free anniversary tastings starting Friday, May 22 at 5pm!|
|Memorial Day and One Year Anniversary Tasting Events!|
|Log Home at Silver Lake|
|A Living Heritage|
|See the Tinderbox's Grills In Action - Memorial Day Weekend|
|Lightweight, Portable Stoves for Campers and Backpackers|
|Memorial Day Weekend - Celebrate Ten Years of Tay Tea!|
|It's Time for Cold-Brew Iced Tea!|
|Celebrate Mother’s Day with Tay Tea!|
|Save the Dates! Tay Tea Spring Events|
|Fiber Arts Weekend at Heather Ridge Farm|
|Sunday May 24 BBQ, Fresh Chicken, New Summer Hours|
|Supper Club this Saturday, May 16|
|Art in the Catskills This Memorial Day Weekend|
|Orquesta SCC Kicks of Summer Season at the Roxbury Arts Group|
|Roxbury Welcomes You This Memorial Day Weekend|
|I Love My Park Day at Roxbury's Kirkside Park|
|Swap Your Seeds!|
|How Do You Celebrate Spring?|
|Dreamy new landmark townhouse vacation rental in happening Hudson|
|Celebrating 'All Things Local' this week with Nicole Day Gray / All Things Hive321 with Theresa Spinelli|
|Celebrating 'All Things Local' this week with Nicole Day Gray / All Things Catskills Grit with Michael Wentland|
|Myth America, Tuesdays at 9 AM on WIOX Radio|
|Thanks to NYNJTC and Upstate Adventure Guides for a Great Year of Trail U at Spillian!|
|Keeping Life Simple - Beautiful Bovina Farmhouse, 2 Ponds & 16+/- acres.|
|Rondout Creek Lodge: Sunny, streamfront home with great room and 2 fireplaces on 53 acres near waterfalls and Blue Hole|
|Spa Treatments for a Cause at the Emerson Resort & Spa|
|Last Minute Savings at the Emerson Spa|
|JOHN VANDERLYN IN VIRGINIA AND WASHINGTON, D.C.|
|Take Mom to the Andes Hotel on Sunday!|
|Oneonta Remodeling Sale Going On At All Catalog Outlet Locations!|
|GCSWCD EDUCATION AND OUTREACH COORDINATOR|
|Raffle for Roxbury Volunteer Fire Department|
|Andes Central School Spring Picture Day|
|New York-New Jersey Trail Conference Is Hiring: Program Coordinator (Catskill)|