Margaretville Main Street buildings face a hard choice: Demolition or stabilization

Above: The Cheese Barrel's window on Bridge Street in Margaretville sported a message of hope in the first days after it was flooded by Tropical Storm Irene. Now the building faces demolition if its foundation is not stablilized. Photo by Julia Green Marks.

According to the Middletown Flood Recovery website, the block of buildings on Main Street Margaretville that was heavily damaged in the floodwaters of Irene two weeks ago can only be saved if the foundation is stabilized. 

The website reports that the Margaretville Village Board met on Friday, September 9 to discuss the fate of the buildings, which are built on the banks of the Binnekill. During the flooding, the rising waters caused the buildings to shift on their foundations.

Currently, the buildings are officially unsafe for occupancy. The businesses located in the damaged buildings include the Cheese Barrel market and restaurant and the Reprise clothing boutique, among others.  

Exactly who will pay for the stabilization of the block is unclear from the Middletown Flood Recovery website's report. Margaretville Mayor Bill Stanton is quoted as saying that the village cannot pay for the repairs, so it may be up to the hard-hit busines owners themselves to front the cash to save their buildings. 

Here's the entire report from the Middletown Flood Recovery website: 

Margaretville Building Stabilization Plan in the Works

Lamont Engineers is working on a stabilization plan for a block of Margaretville buildings that was emptied and barricaded after last week’s flood caused a slight shift in the center buildings. Code Enforcement Officer Pat Davis condemn the structures, meaning that the buildings are considered unsafe, and occupancy is prohibited, until approved repairs are made.

The Margaretville Village Board met September 9 with owners of the four buildings that share common walls. The findings of two structural reports received from private engineering firms were explained. They basically offered two choices — either the entire block be demolished or that the foundation be stabilized. Brendon Becker, an engineer with Lamont which supplied one of the reports, said the latter is do-able and confirmed that he will be meeting next week with contractors to assess the condition of the block, which backs on the Binnekill stream, to develop a stabilization plan to be paid for by the Village. That work is expected to be reimbursed by FEMA.

The plan will be submitted within two to three weeks, along with a cost estimate, and a proposed contractor to do the work, said CEO Davis. It will be up to the owners to determine if they can pay for the project, but Mayor Bill Stanton said all expressed a desire to try to save the block and reopen their businesses.

“The Village is willing to work with them and will help in any way we can,” he said, but he noted that the Village cannot pay for the stabilization repairs.

Owners are being allowed to go into the buildings (no more than three at a time, accompanied by Davis or fire department personnel), to remove remaining debris and clear the basements so that the engineer and contractors can get a better look at the foundations from the inside.