Natural gas: A worse greenhouse gas than it's made out to be, says ProPublica
1/27/11 - 2:54 pm
ProPublica, whose reporter Abrahm Lustgarten is currently one of the most prominent critics of hydrofracking in the media, published a long piece yesterday that casts doubt on the purported climate benefits of natural gas. An excerpt:
Advocates for natural gas routinely assert that it produces 50 percent less greenhouse gases than coal and is a significant step toward a greener energy future. But those assumptions are based on emissions from the tailpipe or smokestack and don’t account for the methane and other pollution emitted when gas is extracted and piped to power plants and other customers.
The EPA’s new analysis doubles its previous estimates for the amount of methane gas that leaks from loose pipe fittings and is vented from gas wells, drastically changing the picture of the nation’s emissions that the agency painted as recently as April. Calculations for some gas-field emissions jumped by several hundred percent. Methane levels from the hydraulic fracturing of shale gas were 9,000 times higher than previously reported.
In addition to new studies from the EPA, Lustgarten's story leans on Cornell professor Robert Howarth, who is currently engaged in an ongoing reserach project to measure emissions from various fossil fuels over their entire lifecycle (meaning, not just the emissions you get from burning the fuel, but also those involved with extraction, transport, etc.).
Based on his research (which, he notes, is still a work in progress), Howarth believes the greenhouse gas emissions associated with natural gas have been vastly underestimated, and that natural gas is potentially on a par with coal in terms of climate impacts. We spoke with Howarth last spring, when he released a preliminary paper on his findings. Here's an excerpt:
WP: You set out to compare the carbon emissions of natural gas to coal and oil. What did you find?
RH: If you look at the Department of Energy's analyses of greenhouse gas emissions from those three fuels, they will say gas is the cleanest and coal is the dirtiest. But that's based on the emissions just from combustion. Energy for digging the pipeline, laying the pipe, trucking the water, hydraulic fracturing, dealing with the waste—those all emit greenhouse gases.
But most important is the release of methane gas. It's hard not to have a little bit of gas leakage when you move stuff over a long distance via a pipeline. The EPA's most recent estimate is 1.5 percent leakage. That's a conservative estimate. We're working on coming up with a better number—and it's going to be higher, frankly.
Reacting to the ProPublica piece in the New York Times's Dot Earth blog yesterday, Andrew Revkin -- a well-known and widely-read environmental and climate reporter -- argues that methane leaks or no, natural gas is still a less risky fuel than coal, and needs to be part of our national energy strategy.
I agree with Christopher Helman over at Forbes who recently wrote that low gas prices mean there’s little to lose by holding up drilling in highly contested areas (the Marcellus Shale here in New York being the prime battle zone) while the E.P.A. review is completed.
But campaigners who fight natural gas altogether, like anyone else immersed in the struggle over an energy policy that works for the long haul, would do well to come up with a real-world game plan for supply sufficient energy to foster human progress while limiting environmental risks.
Photo of Marcellus rig in Lycoming County, PA. From Wikimedia Commons.
|A Catskills forest dweller – the Rosy Maple Moth – Pretty in Pink!|
|A TASTE OF ANEMONE|
|Dicentra Part I (Bleeding Hearts, or why do plant names change?)|
|Dicentra part II (Two Catskills wildflowers)|
|A Living Heritage|
|Log Home at Silver Lake|
|Andes Central School Spring Picture Order Deadline|
|Art in the Catskills This Memorial Day Weekend|
|Orquesta SCC Kicks of Summer Season at the Roxbury Arts Group|
|Roxbury Welcomes You This Memorial Day Weekend|
|Celebrate Mother’s Day with Tay Tea!|
|It's Time for Cold-Brew Iced Tea!|
|Memorial Day Weekend - Celebrate Ten Years of Tay Tea!|
|Save the Dates! Tay Tea Spring Events|
|Celebrating 'All Things Local' this week with Nicole Day Gray / All Things Catskills Grit with Michael Wentland|
|Celebrating 'All Things Local' this week with Nicole Day Gray / All Things Hive321 with Theresa Spinelli|
|Dreamy new landmark townhouse vacation rental in happening Hudson|
|Fiber Arts Weekend and Fresh Chicken!|
|Fiber Arts Weekend at Heather Ridge Farm|
|Sunday May 24 BBQ, Fresh Chicken, New Summer Hours|
|Supper Club this Saturday, May 16|
|Free anniversary tastings starting Friday, May 22 at 5pm!|
|Memorial Day and One Year Anniversary Tasting Events!|
|Frost Warnings... Really?!|
|Repurposing on the Farm|
|Spring Redecorating in the Henhouse|
|GCSWCD EDUCATION AND OUTREACH COORDINATOR|
|How Do You Celebrate Spring?|
|Pizza Gardens for Kids|
|Swap Your Seeds!|
|JOHN VANDERLYN IN VIRGINIA AND WASHINGTON, D.C.|
|Keeping Life Simple - Beautiful Bovina Farmhouse, 2 Ponds & 16+/- acres.|
|Last Minute Savings at the Emerson Spa|
|Spa Treatments for a Cause at the Emerson Resort & Spa|
|Lightweight, Portable Stoves for Campers and Backpackers|
|See the Tinderbox's Grills In Action - Memorial Day Weekend|
|Margaretville Store Closing Sale!|
|Oneonta Remodeling Sale Going On At All Catalog Outlet Locations!|
|Myth America, Tuesdays at 9 AM on WIOX Radio|
|Spillian is Hiring! Special Event Servers Wanted!|
|Thanks to NYNJTC and Upstate Adventure Guides for a Great Year of Trail U at Spillian!|
|Raffle for Roxbury Volunteer Fire Department|
|Rondout Creek Lodge: Sunny, streamfront home with great room and 2 fireplaces on 53 acres near waterfalls and Blue Hole|
|Take Mom to the Andes Hotel on Sunday!|